Notes From the July 31, 2011 Broadcast of Meet The Press
Today’s broadcast started with an outline of the newly emerging compromise on raising the debt ceiling and reducing the deficit. Then came presidential advisor David Plouffe who said the White House’s number one goal for this legislation (beyond raising the debt ceiling) is that it solve the problem until 2013. And the plan currently includes this.


The plan also includes a trillion dollars worth of cuts now and then a second round of deficit reduction to be decided upon by a “super committee,” and this could include both increased revenues and spending cuts. If the committee can’t agree, it would trigger across the board cuts in all (most?) government programs.

Host David Gregory says he has spoken to “top figures on Wall Street” who say this is a “code red day, all hands on deck” preparing for a market shock as early as tomorrow.

Plouffe says that sometime soon, the Treasury Department will lay out exactly what will happen in case of default, specifically who will and will not be paid with the remaining money in US accounts.

Plouffe repeated the White House position that the 14th amendment is not an option for solving this crisis.

Gregory asks Plouffe if Washington’s failure to lead opens the door to a serious third party movement. Plouffe dances in his answer.

Next up were Senators Jim Thune (R-SD) and Claire McCaskill (D-MO). Thune says he wants a plan with no tax increases, spending cuts at least equal to the amount by which the debt ceiling is raised, and a path to entitlement reforms. He says in the current plan being discussed, the “super committee” could include revenue increases, but he hopes that if they do, it will be about reform which broadens the tax base and lowers tax rates.

McCaskill says, “Republicans have voted to keep giving taxpayer checks to Big Oil while voting to convert the Medicare system to vouchers. This does not compute for us.”

Thune likes the across-the-board enforcement option. McCaskill is in favor of Medicare reform which might mean that we “stop buying Warren Buffet his prescription drugs,” but stops short of turning the system into a voucher program.

In the roundtable, CNBC’s Jim Kramer says the range of concern on Wall Street about what US default would mean is staggering. We could easily see a 2 to 3% drop in the markets, maybe more, if nothing is done. He later adds that we are looking at a new recession, this time caused by government.

NBC’s Tom Brokaw adds that a “political default” is already in place. The people now have no confidence in the system. Brokaw says Gov. John Kasich (R-OH) told him the next step in this process should be real reform, not just slashing of spending. He says we mismanaged the growth of government, let’s not mismanage the shrinking as well.

Rep. Raul Labrador (R-ID) says Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid has not been telling the truth about a specific compromise plan discussed last week. Labrador’s focus on the day to day details of these politics is disturbing at this point of the crisis.

A little later, former Gov. Jennifer Granholm (D-MI) makes a point about real economic growth coming from improving the business climate. You might think a fiscal conservative like Rep. Labrador would applaud this. But instead he comes back with a set of facts he brought with him about how unemployment soared during Granholm’s time in office. This was a very odd exchange. What was Labrador’s end game?

Throughout the program, Rep. Labrador showed a tendency to take small differences and turn them into ideological swords. He seemed to have no sense of the gravity of the current situation. He was like a man in a burning building complaining that the chairs were uncomfortable.

Brokaw may have been reacting to this when he pointed out that there are no political winners in this crisis. Everyone comes out looking like a loser.

Later, however, Brokaw said the tea party people did what Americans have done throughout history. They got angry, they got organized, they got people elected, and they brought about change. He said, that path is still open to anyone who doesn’t like these changes.

Today’s Meet The Press transcript will be here.

Also follow the show on the MTP Facebook page, track Twitter feeds from host David Gregory, Meet The Press, and Executive Producer Betsy Fischer, watch the midweek PressPass interview, and don’t forget Gregory’s blog.

Notes from the April 10, 2011 broadcast of Meet The Press
Today’s broadcast began with a review of last week’s budget deal and the looming fight over the next budget and the debt-ceiling with White House Senior Adviser David Plouffe.


Host David Gregory pushed Plouffe on whether or not the Democratic leadership (including President Obama) failed on the budget issue last year and this year. Plouffe tries to keep the focus on the future.

Plouffe repeats that failure to raise the debt-ceiling would be catastrophic. He repeats Speaker of the House John Boehner’s quote about the need to act like adults on this issue.

The big news of the morning was Plouffe’s announcement that the president will lay out his deficit reduction plan this week.

On the plan offered by Congressman Paul Ryan (R-WI), Plouffe notes that it would give millionaires a $200,000 tax break. Instead, he said the president thinks taxes should increase on people making more than $250,00 a year.

Ryan, chair of the House Budget Committee, was up next. He said he feels good about the deal which averted a government shutdown, but the cuts there are just a drop in the bucket. On the debt ceiling limits, he said the discussion must be linked to very real spending cuts.

Ryan brought charts showing an explosion in the growth of the federal debt if we do nothing. Gregory read a quote from Alan Simpson and Erskine Bowles (chairs of a special deficit reduction advisory committee) which said Ryan’s plan doesn’t cut enough from defense and puts too much of a burden on the most disadvantaged people in the country.

Ryan argues that the tax cuts for the rich are offset by closing loopholes the rich use to avoid taxes. And for the disadvantaged, he says we are fixing a system which will fail them anyway if we do nothing. On Medicare and Medicaid in particular, Ryan has a lot of compelling facts about the problems facing these programs. But his plans for fixing them are controversial to say the least.

In the end, Ryan expects his budget proposal to pass the US House this Friday.

In the roundtable, NBC’s Chuck Todd says the whole government shutdown battle made everyone look very bad. Todd said the Republicans are now in the driver’s seat on budget issues. But this also shows that Democrats know how important this is to independent voters.

Gregory reads a quote from journalist Charlie Cook who predicts senior voters will go ballistic over any Paul Ryan-type change to Medicare. Which links to the 2012 presidential race since most of the GOP potential candidates have said very positive things about the Ryan proposal.

On the bright side, MSNBC’s Jim Cramer said unemployment is easing in the country very quickly. And in the end, if the economy is recovering, the roundtable seemed to think President Obama has a very good chance of being re-elected.

Today’s Meet The Press transcript will be here.

Also follow the show on the MTP Facebook page, track Twitter feeds from host David Gregory, Meet The Press, and Executive Producer Betsy Fischer, and don’t forget Gregory’s blog.

Notes from the September 5, 2010 broadcast of Meet The Press
Just a few quick thoughts today:
  • Senator Lindsey Graham (R-SC) said Republican candidates need to be campaigning on “replacing” rather then “repealing” the healthcare law.
  • In one response, Graham revived the term “death taxes,” and David Gregory did not challenge him on what that means. No such phrase appears in the U.S. tax code.
  • Graham said the president is “tone deaf” on a number of issues. He listed KSM, the economy, the mosque debate, and terrorism.
  • David Plouffe, long time adviser to President Obama, said the country is on the right path, and this is not the time to change.
  • Plouffe said this is not a “new” Republican party, these are the same old Republicans. Later he said Beck, Palin and Limbaugh are the leaders of the Republican Party.
  • Gregory asked if President Obama might be challenged in the 2012 presidential primary, particularly by Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. Plouffe batted away the question pointing to how well the two of them work together, particularly this week in the Middle East peace talks.
  • In the roundtable, MSNBC’s Erin Burnett said the economy is actually growing and is rebounding faster than during most other post-recession periods.
  • Rich Lowry and E.J. Dionne had an interesting exchange on extending tax cuts for the wealthiest Americans. Dionne said the Democrats have to draw a line in the sand against this. But Lowry said it makes no sense to raise taxes even on people making more than a million dollars a year.
  • Political analyst Charlie Cook ran through the tightest races in the U.S. Senate. But overall, not much new ground was covered regarding what this all means for Washington, DC and President Obama.
  • Burnett closed the discussion by again repeating that the recovery from the recession (according to the numbers rather than the perception) has not been nearly as tepid as people think. I couldn’t help but think… so why isn’t the White House making this case?

Today’s Meet The Press transcript will be here.